/

Which controller is better for PC?

  • 42
    Replies
  • 5732
    views
  • DoctorEldritch's Avatar
    Community Manager
    @DracoTarot They are sort of real even now, a platinum chip is included in every copy of the Collector's Edition of Fallout: New Vegas. You can't store any data on them, but the sentiment is nice. Unlike that massive fiasco with canvas bags that Fallout 76 had.
  • QueenTomato's Avatar
    @DoctorEldritch I'd love to jump in and give you my opinion but I think it would be quite a subjective one because I'm more familiar with the PS controllers. So I think someone who has tried both would probably give you the best advice!
    When are you planning on purchasing one?
    My farewell mesage 🌟: in English - in Arabic
    Your new MEA Community Manager is @UnapologeticDino!
  • DracoTarot's Avatar
    Level 52
    @DracoTarot They are sort of real even now, a platinum chip is included in every copy of the Collector's Edition of Fallout: New Vegas. You can't store any data on them, but the sentiment is nice. Unlike that massive fiasco with canvas bags that Fallout 76 had.
    @DoctorEldritch would have been nice if they were fully functional. It's an idea I think would boom in the near future.
  • DoctorEldritch's Avatar
    Community Manager
    @DracoTarot I know one guy made a functional one, by making it hollow and putting a flash drive in there, but that's as far as it went for now.
  • DoctorEldritch's Avatar
    Community Manager
    @QueenTomato I do not have the set date or anything, I'm just looking into it and testing the waters for now. My own research was inconclusive, so I am, indeed, looking for personal experience advice. And thank you for the advice given, @j7schultz, @Ken3cento, and @DracoTarot!
  • GoLLuM13's Avatar
    Level 52
    I join the party 😜
    I'm a PS player, so I naturally tend to PS controllers, so years ago I was using one of my PS4 controllers to play on PC, the software compatibility wasn't as good as now and it wasn't even a problem back then, there were always a workaround, but the main thing that was tiring and frustrating (but logical) is that I had to pair again the controller with the PS4 if I wanted to play on it, and if I wanted to go back to PC ... you guessed it, pairing again. So I had to buy a dedicated controller for the PC, when I was looking out for one I ended buying an Xbox One S controller (the one compatible with bluetooth) with a Play & charge kit (the battery and a cable) because I didn't want to manage AAA or AA batteries and I chose the Xbox controller because like @j7schultz said it's just compatible with everything it's Microsoft and Windows is also Microsoft, in addition to that, when you play a game it will always show you Xbox buttons anyway, if I remember correctly, they never showed me PS symbols when I used an PS controller, so for someone like me who never used an Xbox controller like me, when you have a QTE, and they say Y or B and you don't have this on the controller, you're kinda lost 😂. While I'm not disappointed, with the Xbox controller there are things I don't like. The fact that you have to pair again the controller if you charge it with the USB cable plugged into the PC, in order to avoid this you have the choice to whether plug it to an external source like a charger (and not a PC) or to connect it to the PC with a special dongle, there were a discount and I had a voucher, so I went for the latter. And OMG the surprise, when you plug it, it's not recognized, and you have 0 drivers with it, in fact I had to do a search to understand that you had to get the driver which contain some kind of firmware to make the dongle work (yes it's and official made by Microsoft, and the drivers were in the driver catalog website). But once you do it, it's all good for all PCs you plug it in, it's a one time job, and it works good, there's less latency than bluetooth (obviously). There are 2 other points, but they're 100% subjective and personal, because I'm still not used to the asymetrical concept of the Xbox controller, when I play for too long with it, with my hands on the desk, my left hand hurt me a lot, so I have to lower my hands and put them on my lap, and also the sticks are a little bit smaller than the ones on the PS controller, so, sometimes the left stick (the one I use the most) slips from my thumb. Though, I have to admit that over time this kind of "problem" decreases and even becomes rare.
    All this to say, if I had to do it again, unless I have 100% compatibility with PS Controllers and a full visual in-game of the buttons, I'll take again the Xbox controller
  • DoctorEldritch's Avatar
    Community Manager
    @GoLLuM13 Wow, thank you, this is so detailed! So, the PS controller does not have this problem where it makes your hand hurt the way Xbox one does? Also, have you tried the PS5 controller? Looks futuristic a bit.

    That asymmetry you talk about is one of the important issues for me. I never used a controller before, so I do not know if it is easier to play with symmetrical PS or asymmetrical Xbox, to your experience with Xbox hurting hand is helpful here.

    At one point in my life, though, I was a tester for games (tested Titanfall 2, for example), so I tried controllers for all consoles then, but I can't remember if one felt better than the other. Then again, I did not play for that long back then.

    For now, it seems that Xbox is in the lead somewhat.
  • GoLLuM13's Avatar
    Level 52
    Unfortunately haven't tried the PS5 yet, I don't wanna be trapped like for the previous generation, I'll probably wait for the Pro version and/or the Slim to think about buying one if I buy one, since games are coming to PC and some are also on PS4 (God of War Ragnarok I'm looking at you 😁) the interest for this console isn't the same anymore.

    Another info about the PS5 controller, I don't know if it's helpful or not, the PS5 Dualsense won the BAFTA Best Controller Ever Tournament. And I'm not sure (if anyone has it can confirm or deny) but you can use the adaptive triggers with the PS5 controller on some games (or you can add custom settings with a soft) which adds a little of immersion, but for now there aren't many games that supports this feature (even on PS5)

    About the asymmetry and the fact that it hurts me, it's more about the habits and maybe, I'm a long time user of Sony consoles, and sometimes I use Nintendo consoles too, they both use symmetrical controllers, and also if I lay my hands on my laps and not the desk the Xbox controller doesn't hurt me
  • DoctorEldritch's Avatar
    Community Manager
    @GoLLuM13 in my case, PS4 vs PS5 is mainly about how it feels in hand rather than being attached to a console, I have no plans at all to buy one of those. You need a TV for those, and I do not have that either.

    But your comment about waiting for Pro/Slim is interesting, was there a big difference between those versions when it came to PS4?

    BAFTA is interesting, but it is such a personal thing, not sure if I should use it as a guideline. I'd much rather value the personal experiences of the people I know.
  • GoLLuM13's Avatar
    Level 52
    @DoctorEldritch Between the "Fat" and Slim there weren't that much difference, except the size, the fact that it was a little cheaper, and it was colder, and the also tje S/PDIF OUT disappeared, but with the Pro, there were a boost in performance (noise and heat too lol)
    and both came with the DualShock 4 v2 that had some subtle esthetic changes, nothing that we can call a dealbreaker